Did somebody say pie?

How it works

We are an online pie shop. Pies can be ordered and picked up twice a week.

For a Wednesday pick up/delivery - place your order between Friday and Monday.

For a Saturday pick up/delivery - ttc place your order between Tuesday and Thursday.

Flavours change weekly and will be announced ahead of time on our instagram page @NewPieCo and on our weekly newsletter. Subscribe below!


Freshly baked pies, frozen pies, and buns (baked and frozen) are available every week.

You'll have 2-3 delicious pie flavours to choose from. *Only 1 pie flavour will be available in a frozen format.

Each pack of Cinnybuns and Cardi Buns contain 6 buns and can be picked up freshly baked or frozen.

Pick Up

Once your order has been confirmed, your goodies will be available to pick up between 9:30 - 12pm at Kiss My Pans (567 College W) or 109 *Auntie's Supply (28 Bathurst St #1-111) on either Wednesday or Saturday depending on the day you placed your order (please refer to the order schedule above).

*October 16th pick up will be temporarily at Auntie's Supply instead of our Jefferson kitchen.

Local delivery is now available! Deliveries follow the same schedule as our pick up (Wednesday and Saturdays).

*Unclaimed orders will not be refunded. *Please wear a mask when picking up and respect any capacity restrictions outlined by the store.*

Treat Yourself!

Pie Tasting Flight

A tasting flight like no other! We picked some of our bestsellers and new flavours this month and created a tasting set. This month’s pie flight flavours are Oatmeal Scotchie Pie, Lemon Blueberry Pie, Chicago Mix Apple Pie, and Orange Honey Pie. Each pie is 4 inch in size and can serve 1-2 people. 

Oatmeal Scotchie Pie : Wheat Flour, Butter, Brown Sugar, Corn Syrup, Eggs, Oats, Butterscotch Chips, Dairy, Vanilla

Lemon Blueberry Pie: Wheat Flour, Butter, Lemon Juice, Dairy, Eggs, Sugar, Vanilla Extract, Blueberries, Cornstarch

Chicago Mix Apple Pie: Wheat Flour, Butter, Salt, Apples, Cinnamon Lemon Juice, Brown Sugar, Dairy, Cheddar Powder, 

Orange Honey Pie: Wheat Flour, Cardamom, Butter, Honey, Dairy, Eggs, Vanilla Extract, White Sugar, Cornmeal, Orange Extract, fresh Oranges

 *First product photo is just to demo the sizing of pies. Refer to the rest of the photos for actual flavours on this flight. 

Cardamom Buns

Buttery braids filled with our cardamom and brown sugar filling, brushed with a spiced syrup and topped with course sugar. Pairs well with a cozy sweater and some tea. 

Each pack includes 6 large Buns. 

PB Chocolate Cinnybuns

Not your regular Cinnybuns - extra pillowy/extra decadent with our chocolate and peanut butter filling, topped with peanut butter cream cheese icing. 

Each pack includes 6 large Cinnybuns.